Our List of Best Breastfeeding Pumps of 2024

TL;DR: The guide helps simplify choosing a breast pump by evaluating various models based on needs, lifestyle, and budget.

• Types of Breast Pumps: Describes manual, electric, and battery-powered pumps along with their components.
• Choosing Factors: Factors like features, efficiency, comfort, ease of use, portability, size, and budget are discussed.
• Recommended Pumps: Lists top picks for both electric and manual breast pumps, highlighting their pros and cons.

---

Navigating the world of breast pumps can be overwhelming, to say the least.

Do you really need that whisper-quiet electric models that promise speed and efficiency? Or will a no-frills manual pump for breastfeeding work? The market is flooded with options each claiming to be the ultimate solution for nursing moms.

At the end of the day, the best breast pump is one that meets your needs, lifestyle, and budget all while keeping you comfortable. So, sit back mama – we’ve gone ahead and done the hard work for you to find a list of the best breastfeeding pumps to get you started on your search.

Breast Pump Basics

Whether you’re a soon-to-be mom planning your baby gear or a seasoned parent, you likely know a thing or two about breast pumps. These handy devices have been used by the majority of breastfeeding moms at some point, and for good reason. Breast pumps offer flexibility and freedom to maintain your milk supply even when apart from baby.

Breast pumps are amazing for moms who need extra relief from engorgement, are returning to work, or simply want to keep a milk supply for baby. It’s a great way to pump and store breast milk when direct breastfeeding isn’t possible or practical.

Types of Breast Pumps

Before getting into the specifics of the best breast pumps, it’s important to understand your options. The United States Food and Drug Administration explains that there are three basic types of beast pumps:

1. Manual Breast Pumps: These are operated by hand and don’t require electricity or batteries. They’re typically quieter, more portable, and cheaper than electric models but require more effort and time.
2. Electric Breast Pumps: These pumps use a motor to create suction for efficient milk extraction. Electric pumps are ideal for frequent use and are often the top choice for moms returning to work.
3. Battery-Powered Breast Pumps: These are essentially electric pumps that run on batteries. They offer the convenience of electric pumps without the need for a power outlet. They’re perfect for travel or other situations where you may not have access to a power source.

No matter which type of breast pump you choose, it will come with a few standard parts:

• Breast Shield: The cone-shaped cup that fits over your nipple.
• Pump: Creates the gentle suction needed to extract milk.
• Container: A detachable container that collects the milk as it’s pumped.

How to Choose a Breast Pump

As we said before, the best breast pump for one mom may not be the same as another. Consider these factors to help choose the best breastfeeding pump for you.

Features

First thing first, what kind of features are you looking for in a breast pump? Is it important for you to have control of the suction power of the pump? Would you prefer to have the option to pump both breasts for a faster pump session?

You may not need the fanciest model, but consider which features will make pumping more comfortable for you. For instance, moms who need to pump near a sleeping baby or in a shared space may prioritize getting a quieter model.

Efficiency and Comfort

You shouldn’t have to choose between efficiency or comfort! An efficient pump reduces the time spent pumping and can help maintain a good milk supply. Comfort is equally important.

Look for pumps with soft breast shields and adjustable settings that can mimic the baby’s natural nursing rhythm. This dual approach ensures that pumping is as stress-free and productive as possible.

Ease of Use

A straightforward assembly process is a huge plus, especially for new moms or on-the-go parents. Clear control buttons and intuitive settings can make it a breeze to use your breast pump every day.

A pump that’s easy to use should also be easy to clean. This can also save you more time and help ensure your pump stays in great condition.

Portability and Size

Think about where you’ll be using your pump. A compact, lightweight pump is ideal for fitting into a busy lifestyle, allowing for discreet and convenient transport. Some types of pumps come with carrying cases or backpacks designed specifically for this purpose. They even include insulated sections for storing expressed milk.

Budget

Of course, we can’t forget about the budget. You’ll find that manual pumps are the most affordable but are also the most work. A double electric breast pump with all the bells and whistles can be more expensive. Same with hands-free breast pumps.

The most expensive pump isn’t always the best. With so many options available, you can find an option to meet your needs and your budget.

Best Breastfeeding Pumps

Now, for what you’ve been waiting for. Here are some of the best breast pumps you can find on the market this year.

Best Electric Pump for Breastfeeding

Medela Freestyle Flex Breast Pump

• Pros: Portable, rechargeable, and supports hands-free pumping with a smartphone app for tracking.
• Cons: Higher cost and the collection cups may need adjustment for the best fit

Spectra S1 Plus Manual Breast Pump

• Pros: Hospital-grade performance which ensures strong and efficient suction. It’s known for its quiet operation and adjustable settings for both suction and speed.
• Cons: Higher price point compared to other manual pumps. It might also be bulkier, which could affect portability for some users.

Bellababy Double Electric Breast Pump

• Pros: Very budget-friendly with multiple suction levels and modes, comes with milk storage bags and a high-definition screen.
• Cons: Basic design might not offer the same durability as more expensive models.

Willow 360 Breast Pump

• Pros: Wearable and completely hands-free with leak-proof technology allowing pumping in any position.
• Cons: Some users find the suction to not be as powerful and it comes at a higher price point than most other pumps.

Best Manual Pump for Breastfeeding

Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump

• Pros: Lightweight, ergonomic handle reduces hand fatigue, and ComfortFit technology ensures gentle pumping. Also, it’s dishwasher-safe for easy cleaning.
• Cons: Some users might find the suction less adjustable compared to other manual pumps.

Medela Harmony Manual Breast Pump

• Pros: Known for effective milk expression and includes a soft, silicone breast shield for comfort. It’s compact and ideal for on-the-go pumping.
• Cons: Some users say that it requires more manual effort compared to others.

Haakaa Silicone Breast Pump

• Pros: Simple and effective with no assembly required.
• Cons: The standard model lacks a suction base and lid which are only available with more expensive models.

Dr. Brown’s Manual Breast Pump

• Pros: The silicone shield is compatible with Dr. Brown’s bottles for direct pumping. It’s also dishwasher-safe.
• Cons: The handle design may not be as comfortable for all users.

Experience the artistry of custom-made, high-quality breastmilk jewelry from KeepsakeMom. Each piece is crafted with beautiful designs to cherish forever. Shop rings, necklaces, pendants, and more to order today!